Isolation and evaluation of Basella alba linn. Leaf mucilage as
release retardant in tablet formulation
Yamunappa1, Ravi
Kumar*1, Pooja Shetty, Prathibha Suvarna, Narayana Swamy VB2
1Department of Pharmaceutics, Karavali College of
Pharmacy, Mangalore
2Department of Pharmacognosy, Karavali College of
Pharmacy, Vamanjoor, Mangalore
*Corresponding Author E-mail: yamunappa12@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
In recent years, plant derived polymers have evoked
tremendous interest due to their diverse pharmaceutical applications such as
diluent, binder, disintegrate in tablets, thickeners in oral liquids,
protective colloids in suspensions, gelling agents in gels and bases in
suppository, they are also used in cosmetics, textiles, paints and
paper-making. Basella alba is a
wildly cultivated, cool season vegetable with climbing growth habit. Malabar
spinach is high in vitamin A, vitamin C, iron and calcium. In the present work,
an attempt was made to develop matrix tablets of diclofenac using natural
release retardant isolated from Basella
alba leaves and its efficiency was compared with most widely used natural
release retardant like guar gum.
Diclofenac matrix tablets were formulated by using BAM
in different concentrations (2.5%, 5%, 7.5%, 10% and 12.5%) by wet granulation
method and its efficiency was compared with guar gum. The granules prepared
were free flowing with good compressibility. Formulated tablets were evaluated
for hardness, thickness, friability, weight variation, drug content, in vitro
disintegration time, swelling studies and in vitro dissolution studies.
The hardness of the tablets was found to be 6-7 kg/cm2
and percentage friability of tablets was found to be less than 0.1% in all the
cases and swelling index studies shown that as the conc. of polymer increased
there was a proportional increase in the swelling index of tablet. Among the
formulation studied, formulation F5 showed release of drug more than 12hrs and
formulation F5 showed optimum release characteristics. The release was found to
follow the anomalous non-Fickian diffusion. It revealed that as the conc. of
polymer in tablet increased the release of the drug from the tablet decreased.
It shown that BAM exhibited excellent retarding effect on drug release from the
matrix tablets even at very low concentrations. Stability studies were carried
out at 400C±20C/75%±5% RH for formulation F5 for 30 days. The results of
stability studies indicated no significant changes with respect to
physicochemical properties, in vitro disintegration time, swelling index and in
vitro drug release.
KEYWORDS: Matrix tablets,
diclofenac, Basella alba mucilage,
release retardant, wet granulation, guar gum.
INTRODUCTION:
Excipients were defined as ‘the substance used as a
medium for giving a medicament’, that is to say with simply the functions of an
inert support of the active principle or Principles1.
The specific application of natural polysaccharide
polymers in pharmaceutical formulations include to aid in the processing of the
drug delivery system during its manufacture, protect, support or enhance
stability, bioavailability or patient acceptability, assist in product
identification, or enhance any other attribute of the overall safety,
effectiveness or delivery of the drug during storage or use2.
Today we have several pharmaceutical excipients of
plant origin, like starch, agar, alginates, carrageenan, guar gum, xanthan gum,
gelatin, pectin, acacia, tragacanth, and cellulose. These natural excipients
find applications in the pharmaceutical industry as binding agents,
disintegrates, sustaining agents, protective colloids, thickening agents,
gelling agents, bases in suppositories, stabilizers, and coating materials. The
advantages of natural plant-based excipients include that they are of low cost,
natural origin, fairly free from side effects, biocompatible, and
bio-acceptable, with a renewable source, environmental friendly processing,
local availability, better patient tolerance, as well as public acceptance3.
Excipients are also derived from natural sources, synthesized chemically, or
prepared semi-synthetically starting from natural sourced materials.
They range from simple, usually well-characterized,
organic or inorganic molecules to highly complex materials that are difficult
to fully characterize. Classification of excipients is based on their role in
the pharmaceutical formulation, their interactions influencing drug delivery,
or their chemical and physico-chemical properties4.
Excipients are also sometimes used to bulk up
formulations that contain very potent active ingredients, to allow for
convenient and accurate dosage. Depending on the route of administration, and
form of medication, different excipients may be used. To stabilize the active
ingredient, excipients are added, ensuring that the active ingredient stays
"active", and, just as importantly, stable for a sufficiently long
period of time that the shelf-life of the product makes it competitive with
other products. Excipients also can serve to mask an unpleasant taste or
texture and help ensure that the right amount of the API makes it to the right
spot in the body at the right time5.
Robbins has stated, "in spite of the problems
which have beset the gums market in recent years, the fact remains that in many
cases the gums provide a valuable source of income for many poor smallholders
or itinerant laborers, either in very poor countries or in the poorest regions
rather than more developed countries as such they are important commodities ...".
This remains true today. Tens of thousands of people worldwide, living in
regions ranging from semiarid deserts to rainforests depend on the collection
of gums, resins and latexes in order to provide them with an income. Equally,
many millions of people around the world make use of these products in their
everydayLife6.
Mother Nature has gifted India with great variety of
flora and fauna. For centuries man has made effective use of materials of
natural origin in the medical and pharmaceutical field. Today, the whole world
is increasingly interested in natural drugs and excipients.
Natural materials have advantages over synthetic
materials because they are non-toxic, less expensive and freely available.
Furthermore, they can be modified to obtain tailor made materials for drug
delivery systems allowing them to compete with the synthetic products that are
commercially available. Many kinds of natural gums are used in the food
industry and are regarded as safe for human consumption. It should be noted
that many ‘old’ materials are still popular today after almost a century of
efforts to replace them. It is usual to strike a balance between economics and
performance in the face of commercial realities7-10.
Over the Past 30 years, as the expense and complications
involved in marketing new drug entities have increased, with concomitant
recognition of the therapeutic advantages of Sustained drug delivery,
greater attention is being paid on development of oral sustained release
drug delivery systems. The goal in designing sustained release drug
delivery system is to reduce the frequency of the dosing, reducing the dose
& providing uniform drug delivery. So, Sustained release dosage form is a
dosage form that releases one or more drugs continuously in predetermined pattern
for a fixed period of time, either systemically or locally to specified
target organ. Sustained release dosage forms provide better control of
plasma drug. The model drug selected for investigation is diclofenac
which is an non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) drug taken to
reduce inflammation and as an analgesic reducing pain in conditions such
as arthritis or acute injury. It can also be used to reduce menstrual
pain, dysmenorrheal pain. Basella alba which is a fast-growing,
soft-stemmed vine, reaching 10 m in length. Its thick, semi-succulent,
heart-shaped leaves have a mild flavour and mucilaginous texture. The
ethno medicinal plant Basella alba belongs to the family Basellaceae,
and commonly known as Malabar spinach, Indian spinach, ceylon spinach and
vine spinach. Stem, petiole, leaf and peduncles are green in colour. The
perianth tube is greenish white in the basal and pink in apical regions.
Typical of leaf vegetables, Malabar spinach is high in vitamin A vitamin
C, iron and calcium. It is low in calories by volume, but high in protein per
calorie. The succulent mucilage is a particularly rich source of soluble
fiber. The mucilaginous qualities of the plant make it an excellent
thickening agent in soups, stew, etc., where it can be used as a
substitute for okra, Abelmoschus esculentus. Hence there is a
need of development of plant based pharmaceutical excipients for the formulation
of the different pharmaceutical formulations. In the present investigation, an
attempt has been made to isolate mucilage from Basella alba leaves,
followed by physicochemical and phytochemical characterization of the
isolated mucilage, toxicity studies and exploration of release retardant
property of isolated mucilage in sustained release matrix tablets. By
this we can provide inert, less expensive, and chemically inert natural
excipients that can compete with the available synthetic and semi-synthetic excipients
that can be used as an effective alternative excipient for synthetic excipients
for the formulation of pharmaceuticals.
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
Materials:
Diclofenac sodium was obtained from BPRL, Bangalore,
India as gift sample. Basella alba linn. leaf was procured
from the local market in Mangalore. All the other solvents, reagents and
chemicals used were of either Pharmacopoeial or analytical grade.
Methods:
Isolation and purification of mucilage from Basella
alba leaves:11
The leaves of the Basella alba were brought
from vegetable market of Mangalore (India). The collected leaves were sun dried
for 10 days. The coarse powdered leaves were defatted using petroleum ether
(60°-80°C) in a Soxhlet apparatus. The defatted material (60gm) was soaked in
distilled water (1000ml) at room temperature for 6hr.
After soaking material was reflux on water bath at 70°C
for 2 hr. The viscous solution was passed through eight fold of muslin cloth.
Acetone was added slowly to filtrate till precipitation is completed. The
precipitated mucilage was separated and washed thrice with acetone to remove
the traces of water. The separated mucilage was spread on glass plates and
dried at 40°C. The dried mucilage was tested for its phytochemical tests and
physicochemical characterization.
Drug-Excipient Compatibility study:
This study has been done to check whether there is any
compatibility related problems are associated with drug and excipients used for
the formulation of tablet.
Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) Spectral analysis:
FTIR spectra of pure drug and physical mixture of drug
and excipients were recorded on samples prepared in potassium bromide (KBr)
disks using a FTIR Spectrophotometer, (FTIR-8300, Shimadzu, Japan).
Samples were prepared in KBr disks by means of a hydrostatic press at 6-8 tons
pressure. The scanning range was 400 to 4000 cm-1.
Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) analysis:
DSC analysis was performed using Shimadzu DSC-60,
Shimadzu Limited Japan. A 1:1 ratio of drug and excipient was weighed
into aluminum crucible. And sample was analyzed by heating at a scanning rate
of 200C over a temperature range 40-4300 C under nitrogen
environment.
Formulation of diclofenac sodium matrix tablets:
Sustained release matrix tablets of diclofenac sodium
with BAM were prepared using different concentration of BAM viz., 2.5,
5, 7.5,10 and 12.5%w/w. BAM was used as matrix forming material. Wet
granulation method was used to prepare granules of drug using IPA: water
(3:1) as binder solvent, lactose as diluent, and mixture of talc and
magnesium stearate as glidant and lubricant respectively. BAM was included in
the formulations containing 100 mg of diclofenac sodium. BAM were passed
though mesh no. 85 and mixed with Diclofenac Sodium and lactose which
was previously passed through mesh no. 85. The powders were mixed,
granulated with IPA: water (3:1) and the wet mass was passed through
mesh no.12. The wet granules obtained were dried at 40°C. The dried
granules were subjected to dry screening by passing through mesh no. 16,
blended with a mixture of talc and magnesium stearate and compressed
into tablets using rotary tablet press (Cemach, Ahmedabad, India). Similar
procedure was employed for preparation of diclofenac tablets using 12.5%w/w
guar gum as a known matrix polymer. The compositions of each formulation
were shown in Table 1.
Table 1: Composition of
different batches of diclofenac sodium matrix tablets
|
Ingredients
(mg/tablet) |
Formulations |
|||||
|
F1 |
F2 |
F3 |
F4 |
F5 |
F6 |
|
|
Diclofenac Sodium |
100 |
100 |
100 |
100 |
100 |
100 |
|
BAM* |
6.25 |
12.5 |
18.75 |
25 |
31.25 |
-- |
|
Guar gum |
-- |
-- |
-- |
-- |
-- |
31.25 |
|
Lactose |
130 |
123.75 |
117.5 |
111.25 |
105 |
105 |
|
Aspartame |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
|
Orange flavour |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
|
Magnesium stearate |
5 |
5 |
5 |
5 |
5 |
5 |
|
Talc |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
2.5 |
|
Aerosil |
1.25 |
1.25 |
1.25 |
1.25 |
1.25 |
1.25 |
|
Total weight of tablet |
250 |
250 |
250 |
250 |
250 |
250 |
*BAM: Basella alba mucilage;
# All quantities are in milligrams;
# all the batches contained
1% w/w talc and 2% w/w magnesium stearate
Evaluation of diclofenac sodium granules:
Angle of repose:
The angle of repose of granules was determined by the
funnel method. The accurately weight granules were taken in the funnel. The
height of the funnel was adjusted in such a way the tip of the funnel just
touched the apex of the powder blend. The granules were allowed to flow through
the funnel freely on to the surface. The diameter of the granules cone was
measured and angle of repose was calculated using the following equation.
tan θ = h / r, θ = tan-1 (h / r)
Where, h = height of the powder cone.
r = radius of the powder cone.
Bulk density:
Both loose bulk density (Db) and tapped bulk density
(Dt) was determined. A quantity of 2 gm of granules from each formula,
previously shaken to break any agglomerates formed, was introduced in to 10 ml
measuring cylinder. After that the initial volume was noted and the cylinder
was allowed to fall under its own weight on to a hard surface from the height
of 2.5 cm at 2 second intervals. Tapping was continued until no further change
in volume was noted. Db and Dt were calculated using as the following
equations.
Db = Weight of the granules /Untapped Volume of the
packing
Dt =Weight of the granules /Tapped Volume of the
packing
Compressibility index:
The Compressibility Index of the granules was
determined by Carr’s (compressibility) index. It is a simple test to evaluate
the Dt and Db of a granules and the rate at which it packed down. The formula
for Carr’s Index is as below
I = Dt – Db X 100
Dt
Where, Dt is the tapped density of the powder, Db is
the bulk density of the powder
Hausner’s ratio:
Hausner’s ratio is an index of ease of powder flow; it
is calculated by following formula.
Hausner ratio = Dt / Db
Total porosity:
Total porosity was determined by measuring the volume
occupied by a selected weight of a granule (V bulk) and the true volume of the
granule (The space occupied by the powder exclusive of spaces greater than the
intermolecular spaces).
Porosity (%) = V bulk - V x100
V bulk
Evaluation of diclofenac sodium matrix tablets:
The prepared tablets were evaluated for general
appearance, content uniformity, hardness, friability, weight variation,
thickness, diameter, disintegration time and in vitro dissolution
profile using methods specified in Indian Pharmacopoeia. The following
evaluation tests were carried out on formulated tablets which includes;
i) General appearance:
The morphological characterization which includes
size, shape, colour, presence or absence of odour, taste surface texture of the
tablets was determined.
ii) Thickness & diameter:
Five tablets were picked from each formulation
randomly and thickness and diameter was measured individually. It is expressed
in mm and standard deviation was also calculated. The tablet thickness and
diameter was measured using Vernier caliper.
iii) Hardness:
Hardness indicates the ability of a tablet to
withstand mechanical shocks while handling. The hardness of the tablets was
determined using Monsanto hardness tester.
It is expressed in kg/cm2. Five tablets were randomly
picked and hardness of the same tablets from each formulation was determined.
The mean and standard deviation values were also calculated.
iv) Friability test:
Friability test is performed to assess the effect of
friction and shocks, which may often cause tablet to chip, cap or break. Roche
Friabilator was used for the purpose. Pre weighed sample of ten tablets were
placed in the Friabilator, which was then operated at 25 rpm for 4 minutes or
ran up to 100 revolutions. After 100 revolutions the tablets were dusted and
reweighed. Compressed tablets should not lose more than 1% of their weight.
The % friability was then calculated by the following
formula:
Percentage friability =
(Initial weight - Final
weight /Initial weight) × 100
V) Drug content:
Five tablets were weighed individually and powdered.
The powder equivalent to average weight of tablets was weighed and drug was
extracted in Phosphate buffer pH 6.8, the drug content was determined measuring
the absorbance at 276 nm after suitable dilution using a Shimadzu UV- Vis
double beam spectrophotometer 1601.
vi) In vitro disintegration time:
In vitro disintegration time was performed by apparatus specified in USP at 50
rpm. Phosphate buffer pH 6.8, 900 ml was used as disintegration medium, and the
temperature of which was maintained at 37±2°C and the time in second taken for
complete disintegration of the tablet with no palpable mass remaining in the
apparatus was measured in seconds.
vii) Swelling index:
The extent of swelling was measured in terms of %
weight gain by the tablet. The swelling behavior of all formulation was
studied. One tablet from each formulation was kept in a Petri dish containing
pH 6.8 phosphate buffers. At the end of 2, 4, 6, 8 10 and 12 hrs tablets were
withdrawn, soaked on tissue paper and weighed and then
viii) In vitro drug release studies:
In vitro release studies were carried out using tablet dissolution test
apparatus USP
XXIII. Two objectives in the development of in
vitro dissolution tests are to show (1) that the release of the drug from
the tablet is as close as possible to 100% and (2) that the rate of drug
release is uniform batch to batch and is the same as the release rate from
those batches proven to be bioavailable and clinically effective.
The following procedure was employed throughout the
study to determine the in vitro dissolution rate for all the
formulations.
Drug release study was carried out by using USP
dissolution rate test apparatus-II (Electro lab, Mumbai, India). The study was
conducted at 37°C and 50 rpm in 900 ml pH 6.8-phosphate buffer and studied for
drug release up to 12 h. Five ml of sample was withdrawn at different time
intervals, filtered and the drug content was estimated at 276 nm after suitable
dilution.
ix) Data Analysis:
To examine the drug release kinetics and mechanism,
the cumulative release data were fitted to models representing zero order (Q
v/s t), first order [Log(Q0-Q) v/s t], Higuchi’s square root of time (Q v/s t1/2
) and Peppas double log plot (log Q v/s log t) respectively, where Q is the
cumulative percentage of drug released at time t and (Q0-Q) is the
cumulative percentage of drug remaining after time t. In short, the results
obtained from in vitro release studies were plotted in four kinetics
models of data treatment as follows:
Cumulative
percentage drug release Vs. Time (zero order rate kinetics)
Log
cumulative percentage drug retained Vs. Time (first order rate kinetics)
Cumulative
percentage drug release Vs. √T (Higuchi’s classical diffusion equation)
Log
of cumulative percentage drug release Vs. log Time (Peppas exponential
equation)
x) Scanning Electron Microscopy
The optimized formulation (F5) was selected for
Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) analysis. The tablet surface morphology was
studied at zero time and 12th hour of dissolution. The morphological characters
of these 2 scans were compared to hypothesize the mechanism of drug release and
swelling.
xi) Stability Studies:
Stability of a drug has been defined as the ability of
a particular formulation, in a specific container, to remain within its
physical, chemical, therapeutic and toxicological specifications.
The purpose of stability testing is to provide
evidence on how the quality of a drug substance or drug product varies with
time under the influence of a variety of environmental factors such as
temperature, humidity and light, and enables recommended storage conditions,
re-test periods and shelf lives to be established.
ICH specifies the length of study and storage
conditions:
Long term testing 250C±20C/60%
±5% RH for 12 months
Accelerated testing 400C±20C/75%
±5% RH for 6 months
In the present study, stability studies were carried
out at 400C±20C/75%±5% RH for a period of 90 days for the
selected formulations. The formulations were then evaluated for changes in the
physicochemical properties, in vitro disintegration time, swelling study
and in vitro drug release.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:
The powdered dry water soluble mucilage was extracted
from leaves of Basella alba plant for pharmaceutical use. The
standard procedure was used to isolate mucilage and where purified by using
water as solvent and acetone as non-solvent. The total yield of mucilage by
acetone precipitation method was found to be 14.5%.
Additives play an important role in pharmaceutical
preparations like tablet, lotions, suspensions, syrups and ointments. Recent
trends towards the use of the vegetable and nontoxic products demand the
replacement of synthetic excipients with natural ones. Vegetable gums provide
appropriate solution to the current problem. Hydrophilic matrices are an
interesting option when developing an oral sustained release formulation. The
drug release from such matrices can be controlled through their physical
properties. Polysaccharides are the choice of materials among the hydrophilic
polymers used, because they are nontoxic and acceptable by the regulating
authorities. In view of the easy availability of the Basella alba leaf
mucilage, the mucilage from the Basella alba leaf mucilage was investigated for its application as a release
retardant in diclofenac sodium matrix tablet. The mucilage was extracted using
solvents such as distilled/demineralized water, hot water, PBS pH 4.0, pH 6.8
and pH 9.2 and the yield of the dry water soluble mucilage was varied depends
upon the solvents used. Percent yield of the dry water soluble mucilage was
45%, 60%, 22%, 30% and 35% in distilled/demineralized water, hot water, PBS pH
4.0, PBS pH 6.8, and PBS pH 9.2 respectively. The solvents like
distilled/demineralized water, hot water and phosphate buffer pH 9.2 could be
used for extraction for better yield.
Drug-Excipients Compatibility Studies:
Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) analysis
Physical mixture of diclofenac and formulative
ingredients were subjected for IR spectroscopic analysis to ascertain whether
there was any interaction between drug and excipients used. The IR spectra’s
showed similar characteristic peaks at their respective wavelengths with minor
differences. The similarity in the peaks indicated the compatibility of drug
with formulation excipients. IR spectra of the physical mixture of drug with
formulative ingredients were depicted in figure 1, 2, and 3.
Figure 1: FTIR Spectra of
Physical mixture of diclofenac sodium and BAM
Figure 2: FTIR Spectra of
physical mixture of diclofenac sodium and Guar gum
Figure 3: FTIR Spectra of
Physical mixture of diclofenac sodium and Lactose
Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC):
The DSC thermograms for drug and physical mixture of
drug and excipients are represented in figure 4 and 5 respectively. DSC
analysis of Diclofenac sodium shows the exothermic peak at its melting point
i.e. at 283.62°C, which is in agreement of earlier observation and corresponds
to the reported melting point of diclofenac. The DSC analysis of physical
mixture of drug and excipients revealed negligible change in the melting point
of diclofenac sodium in the presence excipients. This also indicated that there
are no changes in its crystallinity of the drug and it may not affect the
stability of formulation and it is confirmed that drug is compatible with
excipients.
Figure 4: DSC thermogram of
diclofenac sodium
Figure 5: DSC thermogram of
diclofenac sodium and different excipients
Evaluation of diclofenac sodium powder blend
Since the guar gum was found to have poor flow
properties, wet granulation method was used to improve the flow properties of
guar gum. A granule is an aggregation of component particles that is held
together by the presence of bonds of finite strength.
Physical properties of granules such as specific
surface area, shape, hardness, surface characteristics, and size can
significantly affect the rate of dissolution of drugs contained in a
heterogeneous formulation. The granules of different formulations were
evaluated for angle of repose, bulk density, tapped density, Carr’s index,
Hausner’s ratio, total porosity and drug content. The results of angle of
repose and compressibility index (%) ranged from 21.84 ± 0.03 to 24.68 ± 0.02,
and 11.01 ± 0.03 to 21.20 ± 0.03, respectively. The results of LBD and TBD
ranged from 0.267 ± 0.02 to 0.421 ± 0.03 and 0.30 ± 0.03 to 0.485 ± 0.05,
respectively. The results of percentage porosity of the granules ranged from
26.92 ± 0.06 to 34.25 ± 0.03. The drug content in a weighed amount of granules
of all formulations ranged from 95.53 ± 0.02 to 98.14 ± 0.05%. Hausner’s ratio
ranges from 1.124±0.03 to 1.192±0.01.
Results of angle of repose (<30) indicate good flow
properties of the granules. This was further supported by lower compressibility
index values. Generally, compressibility index values up to 15% result in good
to excellent flow properties. The percentage porosity values of the granules
ranged from 26.92% to 34.25%, indicating that the packing of the granules may
range from close to lose packing and also further confirming that the particles
are not of greatly different in sizes.
Generally, a percentage porosity value below 26% shows
that the particles in the powders are of greatly different in sizes and a value
greater than 48% shows that particles in the powder are in the form of
aggregates or flocculates. Granule density, porosity and hardness are often
interrelated properties. In addition, granule density may influence
compressibility, tablet porosity, dissolution and other properties. The drug
content in the weighed amount of granules of all formulations was found to be
uniform. All these results indicate that the granules prepared from different
batch possessed good flow properties, compressibility, and drug content. The
results of evaluation of diclofenac sodium granules are shown in table 2.
Table
2: Pre compression evaluation of diclofenac sodium granules
|
Form-ula-tions |
Angle of repose()* |
Bulk density (gm/cm3)* |
Tapped density (gm/cm3)* |
Carr’s index (%)* |
Hausner ratio (HR)* |
Bulkiness (cc/g)* |
Flow-abili-ty |
Total porosity |
Drug Content (%) |
|
F1 |
24.11±0.07 |
0.421±0.03 |
0.481±0.07 |
12.47±0.02 |
1.143±0.05 |
2.375 |
Good |
26.92±0.06 |
95.53±0.02 |
|
F2 |
21.84±0.03 |
0.312±0.02 |
0.364±0.01 |
14.28±0.01 |
1.167±0.01 |
3.205 |
Good |
31.42±0.01 |
95.64±0.04 |
|
F3 |
22.73±0.04 |
0.407±0.05 |
0.485±0.05 |
16.08±0.02 |
1.192±0.01 |
2.457 |
Good |
27.2±0.02 |
95.62±0.03 |
|
F4 |
23.97±0.08 |
0.267±0.02 |
0.30±0.03 |
11.29±0.02 |
1.124±0.03 |
3.745 |
Good |
33.09±0.07 |
96.4±0.01 |
|
F5 |
23.91±0.01 |
0.338±0.07 |
0.385±0.02 |
21.20±0.03 |
1.139±0.04 |
2.958 |
Good |
28.43±0.03 |
98.14±0.05 |
|
F6 |
24.68±0.02 |
0.39±0.03 |
0.44±0.06 |
11.01±0.03 |
1.128±0.05 |
2.564 |
Good |
34.25±0.03 |
97.86±0.06 |
*All values are expressed as mean ± SD,
n=3.
Table 3: Results of
evaluation of diclofenac sodium matrix tablets
|
Formulation code |
Thickness (mm)* |
Diameter (mm)* |
Hardness (kg/cm2)* |
Friability (%)** |
Drug content (%)* |
Weight variation (mg)*** |
Appearance |
|
F1 |
3.60±0.04 |
8.01±0.01 |
6.0±0.16 |
0.55±0.02 |
99.5±0.05 |
250±0.01 |
++ |
|
F2 |
3.67±0.03 |
8.01±0.04 |
5.6±0.08 |
0.35±0.03 |
99.0±0.01 |
251±0.02 |
+++ |
|
F3 |
3.61±0.04 |
8.02±0.02 |
4.5±0.21 |
0.25±0.01 |
98.5±0.02 |
251±0.04 |
+ |
|
F4 |
3.67±0.04 |
8.01±0.02 |
5.0±0.11 |
0.30±0.06 |
98.0±0.01 |
249±0.05 |
++ |
|
F5 |
3.62±0.02 |
8.01±0.03 |
6.5±0.09 |
0.21±0.03 |
98.0±0.01 |
250±0.03 |
|
|
F6 |
3.62±0.03 |
8.03±0.02 |
5.5±0.12 |
0.45±0.04 |
99.0±0.01 |
252±0.04 |
+++ |
*All values are
expressed as mean ± SE, n=5; **All values are expressed as mean ± SE, n=10; ***
All values are
expressed as mean ± SE, n=20; += Average; ++= good, +++= excellent
Evaluation of diclofenac sodium matrix
tablets
The tablets of different formulations were
subjected to various evaluation tests. The shape of the tablets of all
formulations remained off white, smooth, flat faced circular with no visible
cracks. The thickness and diameter of formulated matrix tablets was ranged from
3.60±0.04 to 3.67±0.04 mm and 8.01±0.01 to 8.03±0.02
respectively. The values are almost uniform in all formulations. In a weight variation
test, the Pharmacopoeial limit for the percentage deviation for the tablets of more than
250mg is ± 5%. The average percentage deviation of all tablet formulations was found to be within
the above limit, it was found to be form 249±0.05 mg to 252±0.04 mg. and hence all
formulations passed the test for uniformity of weight as per official requirements. The content
uniformity test was performed for all the six formulations and drug content in the
formulated tablets was ranged from 98.0±0.01 to 99.5±0.05. The results indicated that drug
content was found to be uniform among different batches of the tablets. The hardness of
the tablets of all batches ranged from 4.5±0.21 to 6.5±0.09 kg/cm2. It can be observed from results that the
increase in the concentration of mucilage
in the tablet resulted in a corresponding increase in the hardness of tablets,
which may be attributed to the
plastic nature of mucilage and also due to presence of higher concentration of mucilage, which is generally responsible
for more hardness of the tablet. In the present study, the percentage friability for all the
formulations was below 1% indicating that the friability is within the prescribed limits. The
formulated tablets were found to have good hardness and minimal weight loss on friability indicates that
the tablets can with stand the mechanical
shocks during their handling and transport. Formulations F1 and F2 were found disintegrated within 45 minutes of
dissolution testing in pH 1.2 buffers whereas formulation F3-F6 were found to
retain their shape for up to 12 hours of dissolution testing (table 3).
Swelling Behavior of diclofenac matrix
tablets:
Since the rate of swelling is related and
may affect the mechanism and kinetics of drug release, the penetration of the
dissolution medium and swelling of tablets were determined. The extent of
swelling was measured in terms of percentage weight gain by the tablets. The
swelling behavior of all the formulations was studied. The swelling index was
calculated with respect to time. As time increases, the swelling index was
increased, because weight gain by tablet was increased proportionally with rate
of hydration up to 6 h. Later on, it decreases gradually due to dissolution of
outermost gelled layer of tablet into dissolution medium. The results of swelling
studies show that, as the proportion of mucilage in the tablets was increased,
the percent swelling increased, and the percent erosion decreased. Similar
results were earlier reported for mucilage of Hibiscus rosasinensis matrix
tablets formulated using pure mucilage showed greater swelling as compared with
the matrix tablets containing mucilage and drug. The release of drug from
hydrophilic matrices occurs as a result of complex interaction between
diffusion, dissolution, and erosion mechanisms. On coming in contact with
water, hydrophilic matrices undergo gel formation, and progressive phase
transition from glassy to rubbery state takes place. This results in solvation
of individual polymer chains.
As the swelling continues, the swollen matrix retains more water until the shear forces in the dissolution medium disentangle
the individual polymer chains from the matrix.
It has been observed that the cumulative percent drug release decreases with increasing concentration of mucilage and swelling
index (figure 6).
In vitro Drug Release Study:
The in vitro drug release characteristics were
studied in simulated gastric and intestinal fluids for a period of 12 hours
using USP XXIII dissolution apparatus 2 (paddle type at 50 rpm). Release of the
drug from the matrix-tablet comprising drug, and hydrophilic polymer, the
release should follow three steps. First step is the penetration of the
dissolution medium in the tablet matrix (hydration). Second step is the
swelling with concomitant or subsequent dissolution or erosion of the matrix
and third step is the transport of the dissolved drug, either through the
hydrated matrix or from the parts of the eroded tablet, to the surrounding
dissolution medium.
Figure 6: Swelling behaviour of different batches of
diclofenac matrix tablets
The results show that less amount of the drug
dissolved during the first 2 h in 0.1 N HCl. Diclofenac sodium is a weakly
acidic drug with pKa of 4.2; as a result, it is practically insoluble in acidic
solution. Thus, the lower solubility of Diclofenac sodium in 0.1 N HCl
accounted for <1% release of the drug. Sustained, but complete drug release
was displayed by all formulations in phosphate buffer (pH 6.8). Thus it can be
concluded, that drug dissolution was a function of drug solubility, at various
pH ranges. Indeed, pH dependent solubility of diclofenac is well known. It can
be observed from the results that, as the proportion of mucilage in tablets was
increased there was a decrease in the release rate. The results of dissolution
studies indicated that F1, F2, and F3 released 34%, 24%, and 20% of diclofenac
at the end of 2 hours; and 96%, 93%, and 92 % of drug at the end of 8 hours, 9
hours, and 10 hours, respectively. The high dissolution rate observed with F1
could be due to its low swell ability, indicated by lower viscosity values and
lower concentration of mucilage.
The release of drug depends not only on the nature of
matrix but also upon the concentration of mucilage. This may be due to changes
in the structural reorganization tortuosity or gel strength of hydrophilic gum
polymers. Failure to generate a uniform and coherent gel may cause rapid drug
release. The Formulation F5 showed a slow and complete drug release of 98% over
a period of 12 hr. The results of in vitro studies indicated that the
rate and extent of drug release were decreased significantly with an increase
in BAM concentration, which may be attributed to increase in the polymer
matrix, gel strength and to the formation of gel layer with longer path of
diffusion, resulting in reduction of diffusion coefficient of the drug. When
the BFM matrix tablets of diclofenac come into contact with the dissolution
medium, they take up water and swell, forming a gel layer around the matrix.
Then the dissolved drug diffuses out of the swollen BAM matrix at a rate
determined by the amount and viscosity of BAM in the tablet formulation.
Lactose is the most useful filler used for tablet formulations. It is
water-soluble and would modify the drug release for undergoing dissolution.
Lactose in aqueous solution plays a major role as important physical barrier,
affecting the release kinetics, by reducing the tortuosity of diffusion pattern
of the drug. The results indicated retardant release of drug from all the
formulations with increase in the BAM concentration. Formulation containing
12.5%w/w concentration of the BAM showed slow and sustained release of the
diclofenac over a period of 12 h. From the results it suggests that the nature
of excipient used appeared to play a minor role in regulating the release,
while the mucilage content was a major factor. Lower mucilage content would
result reduced swelling with corresponding decrease in diffusional path length.
Moreover the excipient would either enhance
dissolution or erosion mechanism, depending on the solubility of the excipient,
which compensates for the slowing diffusion rate through the gradually
increasing gel layer by creating greater porosity for the drug pathway. F6 give
70% drug release in 12 hours and which indicate that % of guar gum used in the
formulation it sustained the drug release but the results were not
satisfactory.
Figure 7: Comparative in
vitro release profile from different batches of Diclofenac sodium matrix
tablet and commercial tablet (Voveran SR®)
From the findings, obtained so far it can be concluded
that BAM in the concentration of 12.5%w/w (F5) was promising concentration for
oral controlled release tablet of diclofenac which showed slow and sustained
release of the diclofenac over a period of 12 h. Hence F5 is considered as the
optimized batch. In vitro drug release profile of optimized batch F5 and
the commercial sustained-release tablet of diclofenac sodium (Voveran SR
sodium) were compared; the results indicated that formulation F5 gave the release
profile close to the marketed product. Comparative drug release profile from
different batches of diclofenac matrix tablet. The comparative release rate
pattern of diclofenac from various batches of formulated tablets and marketed
tablet is shown in Figure 7.
Scanning Electron Microscopy
The surface morphology of optimized formulation (F5)
at zero time and at 12th hour of dissolution study was observed. SEM
photographs before dissolution it showed intact surface without any
perforations, channels, or troughs. After dissolution, the solvent front enters
the matrix and moves slowly toward the center of the tablet. The drug diffuses
out of the matrix after it comes in contact with dissolution medium. The images
of the tablet showed the presence of both gelling structures and pores on the
surface. Thus, the presence of both pores and gelling structure indicates the
combination of diffusion and erosion mechanism in the release of diclofenac
from the matrix tablet of batch F5. The SEM photographs of diclofenac matrix
tablet (F5) were shown in Figure 8.
At zero time of dissolution
study At 12th hour of
dissolution study
Figure 8: SEM photomicrographs of optimized batch of diclofenac
matrix tablet (F5)
Mechanism of drug release:
To determine the mechanism of drug release kinetics
from optimized formulation F5, the dissolution data were treated according to
Higuchi (cumulative percentage of drug released vs. square root of time),
Korsmeyer-Peppas model (log cumulative percentage of drug released vs. log time)
equations and Hixson-Crowell model (cube root % drug remaining vs time) along
with zero order (cumulative amount of drug released vs. time) pattern. The data
were processed for regression analysis using MS EXCEL statistical function. It
can be observed from the results that the release rate data of optimized
formulation of diclofenac sodium matrix tablets F5 formulated using mucilage as
the matrix did not follow a zero-order release pattern. By using Higuchi’s
kinetics or square-root kinetics this would explain why drug diffuses at a
comparatively slower rate as the distance of diffusion increases. In our
experiments, the in-vitro release profiles of drug from optimized
formulation F5 could be best expressed by Higuchi’s equation, as the plots
showed high linearity (R2= 0.9908). To confirm the diffusion mechanism, the
data were fit into Korsmeyer-Peppas model. The optimized formulation F5 showed
high linearity (R2= 0.9907, with slope (n) values 0.6661, this (n) value
indicating that coupling of diffusion and erosion mechanism so called anomalous
non-Fickian diffusion and may indicate that the drug release is controlled by
more than one mechanism, which indicate that formulation F5 release the drug by
diffusion coupled with erosion mechanism. Hixson-Crowell plots showed linearity
(R2= 0.9867) indicated a change in surface area and diameter of the tablet with
the progressive dissolution of the matrix as a function of time. The result of
modeling and drug release kinetics of optimized diclofenac sodium matrix tablet
Batch F5 were shown in table 4 and in figure 9-12.
Table 4: Release Kinetics of optimized Diclofenac
Sodium Matrix Tablet (F5)
|
Formulation |
First order |
Zero order |
Higuchi’s |
Peppa’s |
HixonCrowell’s |
|||||||||
|
F5 |
r2 |
K |
r2 |
K |
n |
r2 |
n |
r2 |
n |
r2 |
||||
|
0.8769 |
0.2646 |
0.966 |
7.670 |
32.973 |
0.9908 |
0.6661 |
0.9907 |
0.1855 |
0.9867 |
|||||
Figure 9: Zero order release plot of optimized
diclofenac matrix tablet batch F5
Figure 10: Higuchi plot of optimized diclofenac matrix
tablet batch F5
Figure 11: Korsmeyer-Peppas plot of optimized diclofenac
matrix tablet batch F5
Figure 12: First order release plot of optimized
diclofenac matrix tablet batch F5
Stability studies:
Stability studies were conducted on optimized matrix
tablet formulation (F5) to assess their stability with respect to their
physical appearance, drug content, and drug release characteristics after
storing it at 40°C/75%RH for 3 months. At the end of the testing period, the
matrix tablets were observed for changes in physical appearance, analyzed for
drug content, and subjected to in vitro drug release studies. No visible
changes in the appearance of the matrix tablets were observed at the end of the
storage period.
The drug content was found to be 97.8% ± 0.01%. At the
end of 12 hours of dissolution testing, the amount of diclofenac sodium
released from F5 matrix tablets before storage was 98% whereas that released
from the F5 formulation after storage was 97.5%. There was no significant
difference in the mean amount of diclofenac sodium released from F5 matrix
tablets after storing for 3 months at 40°C/75% RH, indicating that the
formulation could provide a minimum shelf–life of 2 years. However, a detailed
investigation is necessary to determine the exact shelf- life. The results of
stability studies of optimized formulation are represented in table 5 and in
figure 13.
Table 5: Results of stability
study of optimized batch of diclofenac matrix tablet (F5)
|
Parameters |
Before stability studies |
After stability studies |
|
Physical appearance |
Off white, smooth, flat faced |
Off white, smooth, flat faced |
|
Weight variation(mg) |
250±0.03 |
250±0.03 |
|
Hardness (kg/cm2) |
6.5±0.09 |
6.4±0.09 |
|
Friability (%) |
0.21±0.03 |
0.20±0.03 |
|
Drug content (%) |
98.0±0.01 |
97.8±0.01 |
|
In vitro release (%) 12 h. |
98.00 |
97.5 |
Figure 13:
Comparison of in vitro release profile of optimized
formulation of diclofenac matrix tablet (F5) after stability study
CONCLUSION:
Nature has provided us a wide variety of materials to
help, improve and sustain the health of all living things either directly or
indirectly. In recent years there have been important developments in different
dosage forms for existing and newly designed drugs and natural products, and
semi-synthetic as well as synthetic excipients often need to be used for a
variety of purposes. Gums and mucilage’s are widely used natural materials for
conventional and novel dosage forms. These natural materials have advantages
over synthetic ones since they are chemically inert, nontoxic, less expensive,
biodegradable and widely available. They can also be modified in different ways
to obtain tailor-made materials for drug delivery systems and thus can compete
with the available synthetic excipients. Basella alba is a wildly
cultivated, cool season vegetable with climbing growth habit. Malabar spinach
is high in vitamin A, vitamin C, iron and calcium. It is low in calories by
volume, but high in protein per calorie. The succulent mucilage is a
particularly rich source of soluble fiber. Literature survey reveals that
comprehensive physicochemical characterization and exploration of BAM as
versatile pharmaceutical excipients in pharmaceutical formulations has not been
done. Hence, the present study is aimed to enhance the use of BAM as a natural
plant based excipients to develop various pharmaceutical formulations and it
will encourage cultivation and use of this mucilage in the pharmaceutical
industry. In the present work, an attempt was made to develop matrix tablets of
diclofenac using natural release retardant polymer isolated from Basella
alba leaves and its efficiency was compared with most widely used natural
release retardant polymer like guar gum.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS:
The authors are thankful to the Management and
Principal of Karavali college of Pharmacy, Mangalore for providing all the
facilities to conduct the research work and the authors are also thankful to
BPRL, Bangalore, India for generous gift sample of diclofenac.
REFERENCE:
1. Wade A, Weller PJ.
Handbook of Pharmaceutical Excipients. 11th ed, The Pharmaceutical Press:
London, 1994: 426-8.
2. Venkata RE. Chemical and
biological aspects of selected polysaccharides. Indian J Pharm Sci. 1992; 54:
90-97.
3. Robbins SRJ. Gum Arabic,
In A review of recent trends in selected markets for water-soluble gums. ODNRI
Bulletin. 1988; 108: 18-33.
4. Nakano M, Nakamura Y,
Juni K. Sustained release of sulfamethizole from agar beads after oral
administration to humans. Chem Pharm Bull. 1980; 28: 2905-2908.
5. Durso DF. Handbook of
Water Soluble Gums and Resins. New York, NY: McGraw Hill, Kingsport Press,
1980:12.
6. Bhardwaj TR. Kanwar M,
Lal R. Natural gums and modified natural gums as sustained release carriers.
Drug Dev Ind Pharm. 2000; 26: 1025-1038.
7. Desai A, Shidhaye S,
Malke S. Use of natural release retardant in drug delivery system. Indian
Drugs. 2005; 42: 565-575.
8. Chang RK, Shukla AJ.
Polymethacrylates. In: Raymond CR, Paul JS, Paul
9. JW, ed, Handbook of
Pharmaceutical Excipients. The Pharmaceutical Press and the American
Pharmaceutical Association, 2003: 462-468.
10. Hizawa K, Otsuka H, Inaba
H. Subcutaneous pseudo sarcomatous PVP granuloma. Am J Surg Path. 1984; 8:
393-398.
11. Kolen JJ, Mc Ginity JW,
Wilber WR. Carbomer– 934P. In: Raymond CR, Paul JS, Paul JW, ed, Handbook of
Pharmaceutical Excipients. The Pharmaceutical Press and the American
Pharmaceutical Association, 2003: 89-92.
12. Anroop B, Bhatnagar SP,
Ghosh B, Parcha V. Studies on Ocimum gratissimum seed mucilage:
evaluation of suspending properties. Ind J Pharm Sci. 2005; 67:
2006-2009.
Received on 12.02.2016 Modified on 15.03.2016
Accepted on 05.04.2016 ©A&V Publications All right reserved
Res. J. Pharm. Dosage Form. and
Tech. 2016; 8(2):81-94.
DOI: 10.5958/0975-4377.2016.00012.4